 |
|
Treatment of Intermittent Claudication With Physical Training, Smoking Cessation, Pentoxifylline, or Nafronyl
A Meta-analysis
Bruno Girolami, MD;
Enrico Bernardi, MD;
Martin H. Prins, MD, PhD;
Jan Wouter ten Cate, MD, PhD;
Rohan Hettiarachchi, MD;
Paolo Prandoni, MD, PhD;
Antonio Girolami, MD;
Harry R. Büller, MD, PhD
Arch Intern Med. 1999;159:337-345.
ABSTRACT
| |
Background There is no consensus on the efficacy of physical training, smoking cessation, and pharmacological therapy (pentoxifylline or nafronyl oxalate) in the treatment of patients with intermittent claudication at Fontaine stage II of disease.
Methods A MEDLINE and manual search was used to identify relevant publications. Uncontrolled or retrospective studies, double reports, and trials without clinically meaningful outcomes were excluded. Included studies were graded level 1 (randomized and double- or assessor-blind), level 2 (open randomized), or level 3 (nonrandomized). Pain-free and total walking distance were the main outcomes considered; when feasible, end-of-treatment results were combined with appropriate meta-analytical procedures.
Results In 5 level 2 studies, physical training increased pain-free and total walking distance significantly (139.0 m [95% confidence interval {CI}, 31.0 to 246.9 m] and 179.1 m [95% CI, 60.2 to 298.1 m], respectively). In a level 3 study, smoking cessation resulted in a nonsignificant increase in total walking distance of 46.7 m (95% CI, -19.3 to 112.7 m). In 6 level 1 studies, pentoxifylline increased both pain-free and total walking distance by 21.0 m (95% CI, 0.7 to 41.3 m) and 43.8 m (95% CI, 14.1 to 73.6 m), respectively. In 4 level 1 trials, nafronyl significantly increased pain-free walking distance (58.6 m [95% CI, 30.4 to 86.8 m]) and total walking distance (71.2 m [95% CI, 13.3 to 129.0 m]).
Conclusions Physical training increased pain-free and total walking distance in level 2 studies. Only level 3 studies support the usefulness of smoking cessation. In level 1 studies, pentoxifylline and nafronyl increased pain-free and total walking distance, but the average effects were relatively small.
INTRODUCTION
INTERMITTENT claudication is most frequently caused by atherosclerotic narrowing of the iliac and femoral arteries, often in combination with similar lesions in at least 1 of the more distal arteries of the leg. It is the symptomatic expression of inability of the blood flow to supply the oxygen required by leg musculature during exercise.
Intermittent claudication (stage II of disease according to Fontaine et al1) and the underlying peripheral arterial obstructive disease is a common disorder that implies relevant treatment costs in Western societies.2-3 The prevalence is estimated to be around 5% in men older than 50 years,4-5 and the annual incidence increases from approximately 0.12% to 0.19% during middle age to 0.94% after the age of 65 years.6 Follow-up studies have shown that symptoms improve spontaneously in 40% of patients and progress in only 10% to 20%,7-8 leading to amputation in 7% within 5 years.7 Moreover, intermittent claudication is often associated with generalized atherosclerosis, which is responsible for a 2-fold increased death rate in these patients,5, 7 largely from myocardial infarction and stroke, as compared with individuals without intermittent claudication.
Many treatment strategies (nonpharmacological, pharmacological, and revascularization procedures) have been proposed, aimed at eliminating the local atherosclerotic obstruction, slowing progression of the atherosclerotic disease, or simply ameliorating symptoms. The relative value of these treatment modalities is controversial. Conservative treatment of intermittent claudication includes physical training, smoking cessation, and drug therapy.
Physical training and smoking cessation are claimed to be the most effective conservative therapies for intermittent claudication, with the aim of increasing pain-free walking distance.9 A recent meta-analysis of mainly nonrandomized trials10 concluded that physical training should be applied as standard medical care but based this conclusion on pretraining and posttraining results, without a proper comparison group to account for the natural course of the disease. The mechanism that causes improvement with physical training is unclear. Potential explanations include improvement of collateral flow, redistribution of blood flow to ischemic areas, improvement of utilization and extraction of delivered oxygen from erythrocytes, positive influence on the blood viscosity, and raising of pain threshold.11-12
Smoking is a well-recognized risk factor for the development13-14 and progression15-17 of lower-limb atherosclerosis. Discontinuation of smoking is claimed to reduce the risk of amputation.18 Although the pathophysiological mechanism is still unclear, the harmful consequences of smoking could be explained by its adverse effects on endothelium, platelets, and coagulation. Therefore, encouraging patients to quit smoking appears to be a logical step in the treatment of patients with intermittent claudication, although compliance with the advice to quit smoking permanently is generally low.
The vasoactive drugs pentoxifylline and nafronyl oxalate (naftidrofuryl) are commonly used in the pharmacological treatment of intermittent claudication in the Western world19; moreover, pentoxifylline is the only drug approved by the Food and Drug Administration for this indication. The rationale for the use of these agents is based on their ability to enhance red blood cell flexibility and to decrease blood viscosity (pentoxifylline), and to enhance aerobic glycolysis and oxygen consumption in ischemic tissues (nafronyl), although their exact mechanism of action is not well defined. However, the role of these vasoactive agents in the treatment of patients with arterial obstructive disease at stage II according to Fontaine et al1 is controversial.19-22
Because of the uncertainty surrounding the effectiveness of these treatment strategies, we performed a meta-analysis to evaluate the evidence from controlled clinical trials.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
We performed a MEDLINE computer-assisted search of the English-language medical literature (January 1976 to December 1996). A broad search frame was set with the use of the key words atherosclerosis, arteriosclerosis obliterans, peripheral vascular disease, and intermittent claudication. In addition, reference lists of retrieved articles and reviews on the subject were evaluated to identify additional and earlier articles. Studies were eligible for inclusion if they evaluated primary treatment of patients with intermittent claudication at stage II of disease1 with physical training, smoking cessation, pentoxifylline, or nafronyl, independent of their design. Studies conducted on selected populations (diabetic patients, hypertensive patients), reviews or meta-analysis of the literature, and case reports were not eligible. The quality of this selection process was evaluated on a random sample of 100 articles analyzed by 3 independent operators (B.G., E.B., and M.H.P.), achieving a  value ranging from 0.90 to 0.95. Studies were excluded if they did not have a control group or compared 1 of the above-mentioned 4 strategies with another active treatment, were double reports or retrospective, or did not define or assess adequately any of the following outcomes: pain-free and total walking distance or time, ankle-brachial index before or after exercise, rest and peak blood flow, and ankle pressure. For the measurements of pain-free and total walking distance or time, the criterion was the use of a device that forced the patients to walk at a set speed.
Included trials were divided in 4 groups according to treatment type and graded by 2 independent observers (B.G. and E.B.) for the quality of their design in the following categories: level 1, randomized clinical trials, either double-blind or with specified blind assessment; level 2, other randomized trials; and level 3, nonrandomized controlled studies.
Level 3 studies were considered only if no data from level 1 studies were available. Data from included studies were extracted by 2 independent observers (B.G. and E.B.) by means of a standardized form. In case of disagreement, consensus was reached by adding a third observer (M.H.P.). Outcome data were then summarized in tabular format and, whenever possible and justifiable, combined by appropriate meta-analytical statistical procedures.23 The only criterion used for inclusion in the final summary measure of effectiveness was that the report enabled direct extraction of a difference in effect between the treatment groups and its common SD. Only results obtained at the end of the treatment period were compared, provided that baseline values for the outcomes considered were comparable among studies. Tests for homogeneity were performed, and no heterogeneity was detected. Results were expressed as common differences of the means with 95% confidence interval (CI).
RESULTS
PHYSICAL TRAINING
In total, 49 publications evaluating the efficacy of physical training were identified. Of these, 33 were without a control group,16, 24-55 1 compared physical training with another active intervention,56 3 were double reports,57-59 and 1 was a retrospective study.60 None of the publications specified blind outcome assessment; hence, level 1 studies were not available. Therefore, 7 level 2 studies61-67 and 4 level 3 studies68-71 were analyzed. Among level 2 studies, 2 reported data on the same group of patients61, 65; thus, 6 level 2 trials were available for analysis. Details of the study design are presented in Table 1.
|
|
|
|
Table 1. Overview of Clinical Trials on Physical Treatment or Smoking Cessation in Patients With Intermittent Claudication
|
|
|
Level 2 Trials
Sample size ranged from 14 to 50 patients in the 6 included trials. Patients randomized to active treatment underwent supervised exercise therapy (Table 1), except in 1 study,66 in which patients were advised to exercise at home without supervision. In 2 studies the effect of physical treatment was evaluated in patients undergoing a surgical intervention62 or receiving aspirin and dipyridamole.63 In 2 studies patients allocated to the control group received placebo tablets,64, 66 while in the other 2 they were advised to continue with their usual lifestyle.65, 67 Treatment duration ranged from 3 to 6 months, while follow-up varied from 3 to 12 months.
Pain-free walking was determined in 4 studies62-63,65-66 and total walking in 562-63,65-67 of the 6 included trials (Table 2 and Figure 1). Although different experimental conditions (treadmill speed and slope), different units of measurement, and different concurrent treatments hampered summarizing calculations, pooled results of all trials yielded a statistically significant increase in pain-free and total walking distance at the end of treatment in favor of physical training compared with the control group (common difference of the means, 139.0 m [95% CI, 31.0 to 246.9 m] and 179.1 m [95% CI, 60.2 to 298.1 m], respectively). One study reported results on quality of life assessed by means of standard questionnaires; however, it was not possible to extract differences in effect between trained and control patients at the end of the treatment period.61
|
|
|
|
Table 2. Effect of Physical Treatment on Pain-Free and Total Walking Distances in Patients With Intermittent Claudication: Pooled Results at End of Treatment in Level 2 Studies*
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Effect of physical training (level 2 studies) and pentoxifylline and nafronyl oxalate (level 1 studies) on pain-free walking distance in patients with peripheral arterial obstructive disease, Fontaine stage II. Means and 95% confidence intervals for each study and combined for each treatment are given.
|
|
|
There were no statistically significant effects on ankle-brachial index (at rest62-63,67 or after exercise63, 67) or on calf blood flow (at rest63-64 or after exercise62-64,66-67).
Level 3 Trials
In the 4 level 3 studies, sample size ranged from 13 to 42 patients.68-71 Patients in the active treatment groups were given a supervised physical training program. Control patients received placebo tablets in 2 trials68-69 and were advised to continue with their usual lifestyle in 1 trial.70 In the other trial the treatment of control group patients was not specified.71 Treatment duration ranged from 2 to 6 months, while follow-up varied from 2 to 12 months. In general, the results of the level 3 trials were compatible with those of the level 2 trials (data not shown).
SMOKING CESSATION
In total, 7 publications dealing with the effect of smoking cessation on intermittent claudication were identified. Three were excluded; of these, 116 reported data on a subset of patients included in a subsequently published and larger trial,72 1 did not report clinically meaningful outcomes,74 and 1 was a retrospective study.60 Therefore, 4 level 3 studies were analyzed.13, 15, 72-73 Details of their design are presented in Table 1. Since none of the included studies reported similar outcomes, summary calculations were not feasible.
Sample size ranged from 52 to 415 patients. All included patients were smokers on referral13, 15, 72-73 or had stopped smoking within the past 6 months.72 Enrolled patients were strongly advised to discontinue smoking at recruitment; in total, 183 (24.2%) of 756 patients stopped smoking during the 10 months to 10 years of follow-up. In the first study, 41 current smokers were compared with 15 ex-smokers.15 The results were all not statistically significantly in favor of nonsmokers, yielding a difference in total walking distance of 46.7 m (95% CI, -19.3 to 112.7 m), a difference in resting ankle-brachial index of 0.04 (95% CI, -0.08 to 0.16), and differences in resting and postexercise ankle pressure of 11.7 mm Hg (95% CI, -4.5 to 27.9 mm Hg) and 3.7 mm Hg (95% CI, -28.7 to 36.1 mm Hg), respectively. Another study reported that, after 7 years of follow-up, 26 (8.6%) of 304 current smokers shifted from Fontaine stage II to III, vs none of the 39 patients who successfully quit smoking, for a difference of 8.6% (95% CI, 5.4% to 11.7%).72 This finding was not confirmed in a larger study73 in which no different incidence of critical limb ischemia and no deterioration in ankle-brachial index were observed between smokers and patients who quit smoking. However, in the same study, a larger number of failed revascularization procedures was observed among heavy smokers (P=.07). The fourth study did not provide raw data.13
PENTOXIFYLLINE
Of 28 eligible trials, 15 were excluded: 475-78 reported data from a set of patients included in another report published later,79 3 did not have a control group,80-82 and 8 compared pentoxifylline with another active treatment.83-90 Therefore, 13 studies in which pentoxifylline was compared with placebo were analyzed; 12 were level 1 trials79, 91-101 and 1102 was a level 2 trial. In 1 study91 with a factorial design, 3 groups of patients were randomized to pentoxifylline, acenocoumarol, or placebo; these data were also considered for the placebo-controlled analysis. The details of the design of the included studies are summarized in Table 3.
|
|
|
|
Table 3. Overview of Clinical Trials on Pentoxifylline or Nafronyl in Patients With Intermittent Claudication*
|
|
|
Sample size ranged from 24 to 154 patients; treatment duration ranged from 1 to 12 months, and a placebo run-in phase varying from 1 to 12 weeks preceded active treatment in 7 studies. Pentoxifylline was mostly used in tablets, at a dosage ranging from 400 to 1200 mg/d. In 2 trials, the active treatment was administered intravenously, in the first101 at a mean dose of 600 mg/d during 2 weeks and in the second102 at a mean dose of 400 mg/d during 4 weeks. One report included patients belonging to Fontaine stages II to IV.100 However, stage II patients were allocated to an independent group, and the results were reported separately. Therefore, this part of the study was analyzed.
Pain-free walking distance was evaluated in 9 level 1 trials and in 1 level 2 trial. Three level 1 trials did not provide data in an appropriate format to be included in the final summary table.91, 97, 100 The pooled results of the other 6 studies are illustrated in Table 4 and Figure 1, showing a statistically significant effect of pentoxifylline on pain-free walking distance (common difference of the means, 21.0 m [95% CI, 0.7 to 41.3 m]), as compared with placebo.79, 92-95,101
|
|
|
|
Table 4. Effect of Pentoxifylline vs Placebo on Pain-Free and Total Walking Distances and Ankle-Brachial Index: Pooled Results at the End of Treatment in Level 1 Studies*
|
|
|
Total walking distance was evaluated in 8 level 1 and in 1 level 2 trials. One level 1 trial97 and the level 2 trial102 did not provide data in an appropriate format to be summarized. Table 4 depicts the pooled results of 7 level 1 studies yielding a statistically significantly beneficial effect of pentoxifylline over placebo (common difference of the means, 43.8 m [95% CI, 14.1 to 73.6 m]).79, 92-93,96, 98-99,101
There were no statistically significant effects on ankle-brachial index at rest91, 94, 97, 101 or after exercise91, 94, 97 (Table 4). Resting calf blood flow was evaluated in 1 level 1 trial97 and a slight but statistically significant reduction of blood flow was measured in patients treated with pentoxifylline as compared with placebo (-0.4 mL/min per 100 mL [95% CI, -1.2 to 0.37 mL/min per 100 mL). Calf blood pressure was reported by 1 study, and no significant differences were observed among treated and control patients.98
NAFRONYL
Of 11 eligible trials, 5 were excluded: 2 did not report any of the outcomes of interest103-104 and 3 compared nafronyl with another active treatment.26, 37, 105 Therefore, 6 trials were analyzed. All of these were level 1 studies (Table 3).106-111 Sample size ranged from 40 to 180 patients. The study duration ranged from 3 to 6 months, and a placebo run-in phase varying from 2 to 4 weeks preceded the active treatment administration in 5 trials. Nafronyl was only administered orally, with a dosage ranging from 400 to 800 mg/d.
Pain-free walking distance was evaluated in 6 trials. The pooled results of 4 studies are illustrated in Table 5 and Figure 1, showing a statistically significant effect of nafronyl (common difference of the means, 58.6 m [95% CI, 30.4 to 86.8 m]), as compared with placebo.107-109,111 Of the other 2 trials, the data could not be summarized.106, 110
|
|
|
|
Table 5. Effect of Nafronyl vs Placebo on Pain-Free and Total Walking Distances and Ankle-Brachial Index: Pooled Results at the End of Treatment in Level 1 Studies*
|
|
|
Total walking distance was evaluated in 4 trials. The results of 2 of these trials could be summarized (Table 5), yielding a statistically significant advantage of nafronyl over placebo (common difference of the means, 71.2 m [95% CI, 13.3 to 129.0 m]).108-109 The results of the other 2 trials were not in an appropriate format to be summarized.106, 110
There were no statistically significant effects on ankle-brachial index at rest (Table 5).107, 109-110
COMMENT
Intermittent claudication is a disease affecting approximately 5% of elderly men in Western societies, and debate is ongoing about the efficacy of the various generally recommended treatment strategies. Physical exercise and smoking cessation are usually regarded as the first step in the treatment of this condition. The results of our meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials indicate that the initiation of physical exercise in patients at stage II of disease1 is associated with an increase in pain-free walking distance of approximately 140 m at the end of treatment and a similar increase (180 m) in total walking distance. However, these results were obtained in only 94 and 112 patients, respectively, and the effect is likely to be overestimated. There appears to be a large potential for factors such as group incomparability and publication bias to have influenced these results.
The schedule of prescribed exercise and associated results varied among individual studies. In 1 randomized study with a small patient population, a nonsupervised exercise program determined a significant effect on pain-free walking distance as well as on total walking distance after 6 months,66 while in another randomized study that included more patients and with a supervised exercise program, the effect was nonsignificant (Table 2).62 Recently, in 2 small trials, patients with intermittent claudication were randomized to supervised vs home-based physical training; preliminary results seem to show an advantage in favor of patients treated in a supervised setting.112-113 However, no definite comparison is yet available, and prescribing expensive supervised exercise programs to these patients remains controversial.
Data supporting the usefulness of smoking cessation are derived only from cohort studies. They do suggest a potential benefit, but since it is conceivable that successful smoking cessation is associated with other lifestyle changes, the favorable result could result from these confounding factors. Formal meta-analysis was not possible.
The effectiveness of pentoxifylline and nafronyl with regard to an increase in pain-free and total walking distance is well documented. By means of sensitivity analysis, it can be demonstrated that a study of 40 patients in the case of pentoxifylline and more than 1200 patients in the case of nafronyl with a true zero effect (assuming comparable SDs) would be needed to make the results not statistically significant. Based on our results, the average increase in pain-free walking distance is limited to 20 to 60 m. Moreover, studies that assess the effect of these drugs on degree of disability and quality of life experienced by this group of patients are not available. Hence, although the effectiveness of these 2 agents is convincingly demonstrated, especially for nafronyl, it is questionable whether their prescription to patients with intermittent claudication at stage II of disease would be also clinically relevant. In current clinical practice, the administration of these drugs should therefore be evaluated on a patient-by-patient basis. One earlier and preliminary publication showed similar results and conclusions.114 Other authors obtained similar results with regard to the effect pentoxifylline on walking distance.115
We believe our results are generalizable to patients with intermittent claudication who have stage II disease. Although we limited the data search to English-language literature only, the potential for error because of a language bias is extremely low and, if present, is trivial ("Tower of Babel error").116
We conclude that physical training is a potentially effective treatment modality, as is smoking cessation. However, available evidence derived from intervention studies in favor of these nonpharmacological treatment strategies is weak (small samples in level 2 and level 3 studies, respectively). Thus, it is unclear whether prescribing supervised physical training programs to patients with obstructive arterial disease is cost-effective, since this intervention modality is expensive and time-consuming. Data from larger properly designed clinical trials, assessing also the degree of disability and quality of life,61, 112-113 are strongly warranted. For now, advising patients to walk and stop smoking is likely to be all that is required. Pentoxifylline and nafronyl are widely used in Western societies, and the results of our analysis confirm their effectiveness in improving walking distance; however, the clinical relevance of such a small effect should be elucidated by properly designed trials that also assess also degree of disability and quality of life.
AUTHOR INFORMATION
Accepted for publication May 26, 1998.
Corresponding author: Bruno Girolami, MD, Istituto di Semeiotica Medica, Universitá di Padova, Via Ospedale 105, 35100 Padova, Italy (e-mail: girolami{at}ux1.unipd.it).
From the Institute of Medical Semeiotics, University Hospital of Padua, Padua, Italy (Drs B. Girolami, Bernardi, Prandoni, and A. Girolami); and Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics (Drs Prins and Hettiarachchi) and Center for Haemostasis, Thrombosis, Atherosclerosis, and Inflammation Research (Drs ten Cate and Büller), Academic Medical Center, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
REFERENCES
| |
1. Fontaine VR, Kim M, Kicny R. Die chirurgische Behandlung der peripheren Durchblutungsstörungen. Helv Chir Acta. 1954;5/6:499-533.
2. Drummond M, Davies L. Economic evaluation of drugs in peripheral vascular disease and stroke. J Cardiovasc Pharmacol. 1994;23(suppl 3):4S-7S.
3. Rudofsky G, van Laak HH. Treatment costs of peripheral arterial occlusive disease in Germany: a comparison of costs and efficacy. J Cardiovasc Pharmacol. 1994;23(suppl 3):22S-25S.
4. Dormandy J, Mahir M, Acsády G, et al. Fate of the patient with chronic leg ischaemia. J Cardiovasc Surg (Torino). 1989;30:50-57.
PUBMED
5. Balkau B, Vray M, Eschwege E. Epidemiology of peripheral arterial disease. J Cardiovasc Pharmacol. 1994;23(suppl 3):8S-16S.
6. Kannel WB, Skinner JJ, Schwartz MJ, Shurtleff D. Intermittent claudication: incidence in the Framingham Study. Circulation. 1970;41:875-883.
FREE FULL TEXT
7. Verstraete M. Current therapy for intermittent claudication. Drugs. 1982;24:240-247.
ISI
| PUBMED
8. Lowe GDO. Drugs in cerebral and peripheral arterial disease. BMJ. 1990;300:524-528.
9. Spitzer S, Bach R, Schieffer H. Walk training and drug treatment in patients with peripheral arterial occlusive disease stage II: a review. Int Angiol. 1992;11:204-210.
ISI
| PUBMED
10. Gardner AW, Poehlman ET. Exercise rehabilitation programs for the treatment of claudication pain: a meta-analysis. JAMA. 1995;274:975-980.
FREE FULL TEXT
11. Ernst E. Peripheral vascular disease: benefits of exercise. Sports Med. 1991;12:149-151.
ISI
| PUBMED
12. Tsang GMK, Green MA, Crow AJ, et al. Chronic muscle stimulation improves ischaemic muscle performance in patients with peripheral vascular disease. Eur J Vasc Surg. 1994;8:419-422.
FULL TEXT
|
ISI
| PUBMED
13. Hughson WG, Mann JI, Tibbs DJ, Woods HF, Walton I. Intermittent claudication: factors determining outcome. BMJ. 1978;1:1377-1379.
14. Hughson WG, Mann JI, Garrod A. Intermittent claudication: prevalence and risk factors. BMJ. 1978;1:1379-1381.
15. Quick CRG, Cotton LT. The measured effect of stopping smoking on intermittent claudication. Br J Surg. 1982;69(suppl):S24-S26.
16. Jonason T, Ringqvist I. Factors of prognostic importance for subsequent rest pain in patients with intermittent claudication. Acta Med Scand. 1985;218:27-33.
ISI
| PUBMED
17. Kannel WB, Shurtleff D. The Framingham Study: cigarettes and the development of intermittent claudication. Geriatrics. 1973;28:61-68.
ISI
| PUBMED
18. Juergens J, Barker N, Hines E. Atherosclerosis obliterans: review of 520 cases with special reference to pathogenic and prognostic factors. Circulation. 1960;21:188-195.
FREE FULL TEXT
19. Bevan EG, Waller PC, Ramsay LE. Pharmacological approaches to the treatment of intermittent claudication. Drugs Aging. 1992;2:125-136.
ISI
| PUBMED
20. Cameron HA, Waller PC, Ramsay LE. Drug treatment of intermittent claudication: a critical analysis of the methods and findings of published clinical trials, 1965-1985. Br J Clin Pharmacol. 1988;26:569-576.
ISI
| PUBMED
21. Kriessmann A. Peripheral arterial occlusive disease: conservative treatment of intermittent claudication. J Cardiovasc Pharmacol. 1990;16(suppl 3):S72-S74.
22. Radack K, Wydersky RJ. Conservative management of intermittent claudication. Ann Intern Med. 1990;113:135-146.
23. Rao CR. Linear Statistical Inference and Its Applications. New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons Inc; 1973:389-391.
ISI
24. Ekroth R, Dahllöf AG, Gundevall B, Holm J, Schersten T. Physical training of patients with intermittent claudication: indications, methods, and results. Surgery. 1978;84:640-643.
ISI
| PUBMED
25. Sorlie D, Myhre K. Effects of physical training in intermittent claudication. Scand J Clin Lab Invest. 1978;38:217-222.
ISI
| PUBMED
26. Kiesewetter H, Jung F, Blume J, Bulling B, Gerhards M. Conservative drug therapy and walking exercise in stage IIb peripheral arterial occlusion disease. Klin Wochenschr. 1986;64:1061-1069.
ISI
| PUBMED
27. Carter SA, Hamel ER, Paterson JM, Snow CJ, Mymin D. Walking ability and ankle systolic pressures: observations in patients with intermittent claudication in a short-term walking exercise program. J Vasc Surg. 1989;10:642-649.
FULL TEXT
|
ISI
| PUBMED
28. Andriessen MP, Barendsen GJ, Wouda AA, de Pater L. The effect of six months intensive physical training on the circulation in the legs of patients with intermittent claudication. Vasa. 1989;18:56-62.
ISI
| PUBMED
29. Williams LR, Ekers MA, Collins PS, Lee JF. Vascular rehabilitation: benefits of a structured exercise/risk modification program. J Vasc Surg. 1991;14:320-326.
FULL TEXT
|
ISI
| PUBMED
30. Lepantalo M, Sundberg S, Gordin A. The effects of physical training and flunarizine on walking capacity in intermittent claudication. Scand J Rehabil Med. 1984;16:159-162.
ISI
| PUBMED
31. Jonason T, Jonzon B, Ringqvist I, Öman-Rydberg A. Effect of physical training on different categories of patients with intermittent claudication. Acta Med Scand. 1979;206:253-258.
ISI
| PUBMED
32. Clifford PC, Davies PW, Hayne JA, Baird RN. Intermittent claudication: is a supervised exercise class worth while? BMJ. 1980;280:1503-1505.
33. Jonason T, Ringqvist I. Effect of training on the post-exercise ankle blood pressure reaction in patients with intermittent claudication. Clin Physiol. 1987;7:63-69.
ISI
| PUBMED
34. Hiatt WR, Nawaz D, Regensteiner JG, Hossack KF. The evaluation of exercise performance in patients with peripheral vascular disease. J Cardiopulm Rehabil. 1988;12:525-532.
35. Ruell PA, Imperial ES, Bonar FJ, Thursby PF, Gass GC. The effect of physical training on walking tolerance and venous lactate concentration. Eur J Appl Physiol. 1984;52:420-425.
FULL TEXT
|
ISI
36. Boyd CE, Bird PJ, Teates CD, Wellons HA, MacDougall MA, Wolfe LA. Pain free physical training in intermittent claudication. J Sports Med. 1984;24:112-122.
37. Diehm C, Kuhn A, Strauss R, Muller CH, Kubler W. Effects of regular physical training in a supervised class and additional intravenous prostaglandin E1 and naftidrofuryl infusion therapy in patients with intermittent claudication: a controlled study. Vasa. 1989;28(suppl):26-30.
38. Andriessen MPHM, Barendsen GJ, Wouda AA, De Pater L. Changes of walking distance in patients with intermittent claudication during six months intensive physical training. Vasa. 1989;18:63-68.
ISI
| PUBMED
39. Holm J, Schersten T. Exercise training of patients with intermittent claudication. Scand J Rehabil Med. 1983;9(suppl):20-26.
40. Alpert JS, Larsen OE, Lassen NA. Exercise and intermittent claudication: blood flow in the calf muscle during walking studied by xenon-133 clearance method. Circulation. 1969;39:353-359.
FREE FULL TEXT
41. Wisham LH, Abramson AS, Ebel A. Value of exercise in peripheral arterial disease. JAMA. 1953;5:10-12.
42. Jonason T, Ringqvist I. Prediction of the effect of training on the walking tolerance in patients with intermittent claudication. Scand J Rehabil Med. 1987;19:47-50.
ISI
| PUBMED
43. Feinberg RL, Gregory RT, Wheeler JR, et al. The ischemic window: a method for the objective quantitation of the training effect in exercise therapy for intermittent claudication. J Vasc Surg. 1992;16:244-250.
FULL TEXT
|
ISI
| PUBMED
44. McAllister FF. The fate of patients with intermittent claudication managed nonoperatively. Am J Surg. 1976;132:593-595.
FULL TEXT
|
ISI
| PUBMED
45. Myhre K, Sorlie DG. Physical activity and peripheral atherosclerosis. Scand J Soc Med Suppl. 1982;29:195-201.
PUBMED
46. Rosetzsky A, Struckmann J, Mathiesen FR. Minimal walking distance following exercise treatment in patients with arterial occlusive disease. Ann Chir Gynaecol. 1985;74:261-264.
ISI
| PUBMED
47. Pancera P, Prior M, Zannoni M, Lucchese L, De Marchi S, Arosio E. Micro- and macrocirculatory, and biohumoral changes after a month of physical exercise in patients with intermittent claudication. Scand J Rehabil Med. 1995;27:73-76.
ISI
| PUBMED
48. Skinner JS, Strandness DE Jr. Exercise and intermittent claudication: effect of physical training. Circulation. 1967;36:23-29.
FREE FULL TEXT
49. Hall JA, Barnard RJ. The effects of an intensive 26-day program of diet and exercise on patients with peripheral vascular disease. J Cardiac Rehabil. 1982;2:569-574.
50. Pritikin N, Kern J, Kaye SM. Diet and exercise as a total therapeutic regimen for the rehabilitation of patients with severe peripheral vascular disease. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 1975;56:558.
51. Zetterqvist S. The effect of active training on the nutritive blood flow in exercising ischemic legs. Scand J Clin Lab Invest. 1970;25:101-111.
ISI
| PUBMED
52. Skinner JS, Strandness DE. Exercise and intermittent claudication: effect of repetition and intensity of exercise. Circulation. 1967;36:15-22.
FREE FULL TEXT
53. Blumchen G, Landry F, Kiefer H, Schlosser V. Hemodynamic response of claudicating extremities: evaluation of a long range exercise program. Cardiology. 1970;55:114-127.
FULL TEXT
|
ISI
| PUBMED
54. Jonason T, Ringqvist I, Öman-Rydberg A. Home-training of patients with intermittent claudication. Scand J Rehabil Med. 1981;13:137-141.
ISI
| PUBMED
55. Johnson EC, Voyles WF, Atterbom HA, Pathak D, Sutton MF, Greene ER. Effects of exercise training on common femoral artery blood flow in patients with intermittent claudication. Circulation. 1989;80(suppl III):III-59–III-72.
56. Perkins JMT, Collin J, Creasy TS, Fletcher EWL, Morris PJ. Exercise training versus angioplasty for stable claudication: long and medium term results of a prospective, randomised trial. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 1996;11:409-413.
FULL TEXT
|
ISI
| PUBMED
57. Lundgren F, Dahllöf AG, Schersten T, Bylund-Fellenius AC. Muscle enzyme adaption in patients with peripheral arterial insufficiency: spontaneous adaption, effect of different treatments and consequences on walking performance. Clin Sci. 1989;77:485-493.
PUBMED
58. Holm J, Dahllöf AG, Bjorntorp P, Schersten T. Enzyme studies in muscles of patients with intermittent claudication: effect of training. Scand J Clin Lab Invest. 1973;128(suppl):201-205.
59. Larsen OA, Lassen NA. Effect of daily muscular exercise in patients with intermittent claudication. Scand J Clin Lab Invest 1966;99(suppl):168-171.
60. Cronenwett JL, Warner KG, Zelenock GB, et al. Intermittent claudication: current results of nonoperative management. Arch Surg. 1984;119:430-436.
FREE FULL TEXT
61. Regensteiner JG, Steiner JF, Hiatt WR. Exercise improves functional status in patients with peripheral arterial disease. J Vasc Surg. 1996;23:104-115.
FULL TEXT
|
ISI
| PUBMED
62. Lundgren F, Dahllöf AG, Lundholm K, Schersten T, Volkmann R. Intermittent claudication: surgical reconstruction or physical training? a prospective randomized trial of treatment efficiency. Ann Surg. 1989;209:346-355.
ISI
| PUBMED
63. Mannarino E, Pasqualini L, Innocente S, Scricciolo V, Rignanese A, Ciuffetti G. Physical training and antiplatelet treatment in stage II peripheral arterial occlusive disease: alone or combined? Angiology. 1991;42:513-521.
64. Dahllöf AG, Bjorntorp P, Holm J, Schersten T. Metabolic activity of skeletal muscle in patients with peripheral arterial insufficiency: effect of physical training. Eur J Clin Invest. 1974;4:9-15.
ISI
| PUBMED
65. Hiatt WR, Wolfel EE, Meier RH, Regensteiner JG. Superiority of treadmill walking exercise versus strength training for patients with peripheral arterial disease. Circulation. 1994;90:1866-1874.
FREE FULL TEXT
66. Larsen OA, Lassen NA. Effect of daily muscular exercise in patients with intermittent claudication. Lancet. 1966;2:1093-1096.
ISI
| PUBMED
67. Hiatt WR, Regensteiner JG, Hargarten ME, Wolfel EE, Brass EP. Benefit of exercise conditioning for patients with peripheral arterial disease. Circulation. 1990;81:602-609.
FREE FULL TEXT
68. Dahllöf AG, Holm J, Schersten T, Sivertsson R. Peripheral arterial insufficiency: effect of physical training on walking tolerance, calf blood flow, and blood flow resistance. Scand J Rehabil Med. 1976;8:19-26.
69. Mannarino E, Pasqualini L, Menna M, Maragoni G, Orlandi U. Effects of physical training on peripheral vascular disease: a controlled study. Angiology. 1989;40:5-10.
70. Ernst EEW, Matrai A. Intermittent claudication, exercise, and blood rheology. Circulation. 1987;76:1110-1114.
FREE FULL TEXT
71. Ericsson B, Haeger K, Lindell SE. Effect of physical training on intermittent claudication. Angiology. 1970;21:188-192.
72. Jonason T, Bergstrom R. Cessation of smoking in patients with intermittent claudication. Acta Med Scand. 1987;221:253-260.
ISI
| PUBMED
73. Smith I, Franks PJ, Greenhalgh RM, Poulter NR, Powell JT. The influence of smoking cessation and hypertriglyceridaemia on the progression of peripheral arterial disease and the onset of critical ischaemia. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 1996;11:402-408.
FULL TEXT
|
ISI
| PUBMED
74. Vasli LR, Foss OP. Serum thiocyanate, smoking habits and smoking cessation trial in patients with peripheral atherosclerosis. Scand J Clin Lab Invest. 1987;47:399-403.
ISI
| PUBMED
75. Porter JM, Baur GM. Pharmacologic treatment of intermittent claudication. Surgery. 1982;92:966-971.
ISI
| PUBMED
76. Reich T, Gillings D. Effects of pentoxifylline on severe intermittent claudication. Angiology. 1987;38:651-656.
77. Reich T, Cutler BC, Lee BY, et al. Pentoxifylline in the treatment of intermittent claudication of the lower limbs. Angiology. 1984;35:389-395.
78. Porter JM, Cutler BS, Lee BY, et al. Pentoxifylline efficacy in the treatment of intermittent claudication: multicenter controlled double-blind trial with objective assessment of chronic occlusive arterial disease patients. Am Heart J. 1982;104:66-72.
FULL TEXT
|
ISI
| PUBMED
79. Gillings D, Koch G, Reich T, Stager WJ. Another look at the pentoxifylline efficacy data for intermittent claudication. J Clin Pharmacol. 1987;27:601-609.
ABSTRACT
80. Roeren T, LeVeen RF, Nugent L. Photoplethysmographic documentation of improved microcirculation after pentoxifylline therapy. Angiology. 1988;39:929-933.
81. AbuRahma AF, Woodruff BA. Effects and limitations of pentoxifylline therapy in various stages of peripheral vascular disease of the lower extremity. Am J Surg. 1990;160:266-270.
ISI
| PUBMED
82. Poggesi L, Scarti L, Boddi M, Masotti G, Serneri GG. Pentoxifylline treatment in patients with occlusive peripheral arterial disease: circulatory changes and effects on prostaglandin synthesis. Angiology. 1985;36:628-637.
83. Pignoli P, Ciccolo F, Villa V, Longo T. Comparative evaluation of buflomedil and pentoxiphylline in patients with peripheral arterial occlusive disease. Curr Ther Res. 1985;37:596-606.
84. Chacon-Quevedo A, Eguaras MG, Calleja F, et al. Comparative evaluation of pentoxifylline, buflomedil, and nifedipine in the treatment of intermittent claudication of the lower limbs. Angiology. 1994;45:647-653.
85. Perhoniemi V, Salmenkivi K, Sundberg S, Johnsson R, Gordin A. Effects of flunarizine and pentoxifylline on walking distance and blood rheology in claudication. Angiology. 1984;35:366-372.
86. Feine-Haake G. Assessment of the therapeutic efficacy of pentoxifylline (Trental): a double-blind trial in geriatric patients with vascular disorder. Pharmatherapeutica. 1983;3(suppl 1):46-51.
87. Accetto B. Beneficial hemorheologic therapy of chronic peripheral arterial disorders with pentoxifylline: results of a double-blind study versus vasodilator-nylidrin. Am Heart J. 1982;103:864-869.
FULL TEXT
|
ISI
| PUBMED
88. Trübestein G, Trübestein R, Duong QD. Comparative evaluation of the effectiveness of buflomedil and pentoxiphylline in patients with arterial occlusive disease. Angiology. 1981;32:705-709.
89. Mashiah A, Patel P, Schraibman IG, Charlesworth D. Drug therapy in intermittent claudication: an objective assessment of the effects of three drugs in patients with intermittent claudication. Br J Surg. 1978;65:342-345.
ISI
| PUBMED
90. Deutschinoff A, Grozdinsky L. Rheological and anticoagulant therapy of patients with chronic peripheral occlusive arterial disease (COAD). Angiology. 1987;38:351-358.
91. Dettori AG, Pini M, Moratti A, et al. Acenocoumarol and pentoxifylline in intermittent claudication: a controlled clinical study. Angiology. 1989;40:237-248.
92. Ernst E, Kollar L, Resch KL. Does pentoxifylline prolong the walking distance in exercised claudicants? a placebo-controlled double-blind trial. Angiology. 1992;43:121-125.
93. Lindgärde F, Jelnes R, Bjorkman H, et al. Conservative drug treatment in patients with moderately severe chronic occlusive peripheral arterial disease. Circulation. 1989;80:1549-1556.
FREE FULL TEXT
94. Donaldson DR, Hall TJ, Kester RC, Ramsden CW, Wiggins PA. Does oxpentifylline (Trental) have a place in the treatment of intermittent claudication? Curr Med Res Opin. 1984;9:35-40.
ISI
| PUBMED
95. Di Perri T, Guerrini M. Placebo controlled double blind study with pentoxifylline of walking performance in patients with intermittent claudication. Angiology. 1983;34:40-45.
96. Reilly DT, Quinton DN, Barrie WW. A controlled trial of pentoxifylline (Trental 400) in intermittent claudication: clinical, haemostatic and rheological effects. N Z Med J. 1987;100:445-447.
ISI
| PUBMED
97. Gallus AS, Gleadow F, Dupont P, et al. Intermittent claudication: a double-blind crossover trial of pentoxifylline. Aust N Z J Med. 1985;15:402-409.
ISI
| PUBMED
98. Bollinger A, Frei CH. Double-blind trial of pentoxifylline against placebo in patients with intermittent claudication. Pharmatherapeutica. 1977;1:557-561.
ISI
99. Volker D. Treatment of artheriopathies with pentoxifylline (Trental 400): results of a double-blind study. Pharmatherapeutica. 1983;3(suppl 1):136-142.
100. Tonak J, Knecht H, Groitl H. Treatment of circulatory disturbances with pentoxifylline: double-blind study with Trental. Pharmatherapeutica. 1983;3(suppl 1):126-135.
101. Rudofsky G, Haussler KF, Künkel HP, et al. Intravenous treatment of chronic peripheral occlusive arterial disease: a double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized, multicenter trial of pentoxifylline. Angiology. 1989;40:639-649.
102. Scheffler P, de la Hamette D, Gross J, Mueller H, Schieffer H. Intensive vascular training in stage IIb in peripheral arterial occlusive disease: the additive effects of intravenous prostaglandin E1 or intravenous pentoxifylline during training. Circulation. 1994;90:818-822.
FREE FULL TEXT
103. Waters KJ, Craxford AD, Chamberlain J. The effect of naftidrofuryl (Praxilene) on intermittent claudication. Br J Surg. 1980;67:349-351.
ISI
| PUBMED
104. Ruckley CV, Callam MJ, Ferrington CM, Prescott RJ. Naftidrofuryl for intermittent claudication: a double-blind controlled trial. BMJ. 1978;1:620.
105. Rosas G, Cerdeyra C, Lucas MA, Parano JR, Villa JJ. Comparison of safety and efficacy of buflomedil and naftidrofuryl in the treatment of intermittent claudication. Angiology. 1981;32:291-297.
106. Karnik R, Valentin A, Stöllberger C, Slany J. Effects of naftidrofuryl in patients with intermittent claudication. Angiology. 1988;39:234-240.
107. Adhoute G, Bacourt F, Barral M, et al. Naftidrofuryl in chronic arterial disease: results of a six month controlled multicenter study using naftidrofuryl tablets 200 mg. Angiology. 1986;37:160-167.
108. Trübestein G, Böhme H, Heidrich H, et al. Naftidrofuryl in chronic arterial occlusive disease: results of a controlled multicenter study. Angiology. 1984;35:701-708.
109. Adhoute G, Andreassian H, Boccalon M, et al. Treatment of stage II chronic arterial disease of the lower limbs with the serotoninergic antagonist naftidrofuryl: results after six months of a controlled multicenter study. J Cardiovasc Pharmacol. 1990;16(suppl 3):S75-S80.
110. Moody AP, Al-Khaffaf HS, Lehert P, Harris PL, Charlesworth D. An evaluation of patients with severe intermittent claudication and the effect of treatment with naftidrofuryl. J Cardiovasc Pharmacol. 1994;23(suppl 3):S44-S47.
111. Clyne CAC, Galland RB, Fox MJ, Gustave R, Jantet GH, Jamieson CW. A controlled trial of naftidrofuryl (Praxilene) in the treatment of intermittent claudication. Br J Surg. 1980;67: 347-348.
112. Patterson RB, Pinto B, Marcus B, Colucci A, Braun T, Roberts M. Value of a supervised exercise program for the therapy of arterial claudication. J Vasc Surg. 1997;25:312-319.
FULL TEXT
|
ISI
| PUBMED
113. Regensteiner JG, Meyer TJ, Krupski WC, Cranford LS, Hiatt WR. Hospital- vs home-based exercise rehabilitation for patients with peripheral arterial occlusive disease. Angiology. 1997;48:291-300.
114. Girolami B, Bernardi E, Koelemay M, Prandoni P, Girolami A, Prins MH. Pharmacological treatment of peripheral arterial occlusive disease (Fontaine's stage II): a meta-analysis of randomised clinical trials [abstract]. Thromb Haemost. 1995;6:1386.
115. Hood SC, Moher D, Barber GG. Management of intermittent claudication with pentoxifylline: meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. CMAJ. 1996;155:1053-1059.
ABSTRACT
116. Grégorie G, Derderian F, Le Lorier J. Selecting the language of the publications included in a meta-analysis: is there a Tower of Babel bias? J Clin Epidemiol. 1995;48:159-163.
FULL TEXT
|
ISI
| PUBMED
 CiteULike  Connotea  Del.icio.us  Digg  Reddit  Technorati  Twitter
What's this?
THIS ARTICLE HAS BEEN CITED BY OTHER ARTICLES
|
Naftidrofuryl for intermittent claudication: meta-analysis based on individual patient data
De Backer et al.
BMJ 2009;338:b603-b603.
ABSTRACT
| FULL TEXT
Effects of Cilostazol and Pentoxifylline on Forearm Reactive Hyperemia Response, Lipid Profile, Oxidative Stress, and Inflammatory Markers in Patients With Intermittent Claudication
de Albuquerque et al.
ANGIOLOGY 2008;59:549-558.
ABSTRACT
Peripheral Arterial Disease: Diagnosis and Management
Arain and Cooper
Mayo Clin Proc. 2008;83:944-950.
ABSTRACT
| FULL TEXT
Levo-Propionyl-Carnitine Improves the Effectiveness of Supervised Physical Training on the Absolute Claudication Distance in Patients With Intermittent Claudication
Andreozzi et al.
ANGIOLOGY 2008;59:84-89.
ABSTRACT
Current Treatment of Peripheral Arterial Disease: Role of Percutaneous Interventional Therapies
Mahmud et al.
J Am Coll Cardiol 2007;50:473-490.
ABSTRACT
| FULL TEXT
Exercise and Peripheral Arterial Disease
Kim
ANN INTERN MED 2006;144:699-699.
FULL TEXT
ACC/AHA 2005 Guidelines for the Management of Patients With Peripheral Arterial Disease (Lower Extremity, Renal, Mesenteric, and Abdominal Aortic): Executive Summary A Collaborative Report From the American Association for Vascular Surgery/Society for Vascular Surgery, Society for Cardiovascular Angiography and Interventions, Society for Vascular Medicine and Biology, Society of Interventional Radiology, and the ACC/AHA Task Force on Practice Guidelines (Writing Committee to Develop Guidelines for the Management of Patients With Peripheral Arterial Disease): Endorsed by the American Association of Cardiovascular and Pulmonary Rehabilitation; National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute; Society for Vascular Nursing; TransAtlantic Inter-Society Consensus; and Vascular Disease Foundation
Hirsch et al.
J Am Coll Cardiol 2006;47:1239-1312.
FULL TEXT
Medical Treatment of Peripheral Arterial Disease
Hankey et al.
JAMA 2006;295:547-553.
ABSTRACT
| FULL TEXT
Popliteal-to-Distal Bypass: Identifying Risk Factors Associated with Limb Loss and Graft Failure
Galaria et al.
VASC ENDOVASCULAR SURG 2005;39:393-400.
ABSTRACT
Atherosclerotic Vascular Disease Conference: Writing Group V: Medical Decision Making and Therapy
Creager et al.
Circulation 2004;109:2634-2642.
FULL TEXT
Leg Ulcers and Pain: A Review
Cooper et al.
INT J LOW EXTREM WOUNDS 2003;2:189-197.
ABSTRACT
Peripheral Arterial Disease: Identification and Implications
Mohler
Arch Intern Med 2003;163:2306-2314.
ABSTRACT
| FULL TEXT
Endogenous vascular remodeling in ischemic skeletal muscle: a role for nitric oxide
Buckwalter et al.
J. Appl. Physiol. 2003;94:935-940.
ABSTRACT
| FULL TEXT
Consultations on Patients with Venous or Arterial Diseases
Alving et al.
ASH Education Book 2003;2003:540-558.
ABSTRACT
| FULL TEXT
Exercise Training for Claudication
Stewart et al.
NEJM 2002;347:1941-1951.
FULL TEXT
Pharmacologic treatment for intermittent claudication
Dean
Vasc Med 2002;7:301-309.
ABSTRACT
Physical training for intermittent claudication: a comparison of structured rehabilitation versus home-based training
Degischer et al.
Vasc Med 2002;7:109-115.
ABSTRACT
Risk factor modification in intermittent claudication: effect on life expectancy and walking capacity
Hiatt
Eur Heart J Suppl 2002;4:B50-B54.
ABSTRACT
Coronary artery disease and intermittent claudication: how to manage the patient
Perrone-Filardi and Chiariello
Eur Heart J Suppl 2002;4:B58-B62.
ABSTRACT
Managing peripheral arterial disease in primary care
DTB 2002;40:5-8.
ABSTRACT
| FULL TEXT
Medical Treatment of Peripheral Arterial Disease and Claudication
Hiatt
NEJM 2001;344:1608-1621.
FULL TEXT
Stimulation of arteriogenesis; a new concept for the treatment of arterial occlusive disease
van Royen et al.
Cardiovasc Res 2001;49:543-553.
ABSTRACT
| FULL TEXT
Intermittent Claudication Revisited: The Value of Medical Therapy
Hiatt et al.
Arch Intern Med 1999;159:1955-1956.
FULL TEXT
|
